Well.. I think we all remember when I was playing Oskar.
The only HM I've ever cided not because I was bored but because the guild was too frustrating to play.
I kept track and every spell over level 8 had at least one bug that I found in the first day of getting it. Some were fixed, one spell was removed to be fixed (over a year ago), and some bugs I didn't even catch and were noticed by other people.. in the same spells!
There is a lot of room for abuse in that guild but even if you DO abuse all the bugs you still can't level magic decently at all.
Although I think we've discussed privately Muod how the guild could be playable with 3-4 very easy changes 
_________________________
If you say plz because it is shorter than please, then I will say no because it is shorter then yes.
