i'd do it as a physical hit back and when it beats it by enough, I do like that idea though i'd probably like to see a riposet skill since if it was just part of defense skills as a whole I think it'd be too good of a bonus to them heh
If it were a separate skill, it should definitely crit, I think (a crit from your weapon). If all you got was a base damage hit back, I doubt the skill would be worth investing precious, life-giving devs into.
